Rejecting the yoke of Village People tyranny
Last night, my phone rang at 2:20, just after the thunderstorms passed through. It was a wrong number, and I stumbled back to bed. I remained sleepless, though, and heard the radios of passing cars on our mildly-busy street. One car was blasting the Village People. At 3 a.m.
In the midst of my state, somewhere between sleeping and waking, I realized something profound: This may be the year that two of the worst songs in history have been defeated by the Forces of Good.
We have shot 11 weddings this summer, with a 12th on Saturday. Not ONCE has the DJ played the "YMCA" or the "Macarena." These weddings have included a cross-section of humanity; people of different educational, socio-economic, and racial backgrounds. Weddings that cost at least $70,000, and weddings that probably didn't cost $2,000.
It's as if the whole world came to its sense to break these chains of oppression! I never saw anyone between the ages of 10 and 60 who actually enjoyed the "YMCA." Most people groaned when it came on. Most couples hated it. And yet every doggone DJ in NW Ohio and SE Michigan considered themselves an abject failure if they neglected to play the song. It was like they were giving some religiously-mandated alms - they didn't really want to, but knew that they had to.
The fact that this change has happened is interesting to me, but not nearly as much as why it has happened.
Here's my theory (and it's a theory hatched on about 4 hrs sleep, so bear with me):
Wedding trends tend to spread virally. Think about it: Ten years ago, everyone threw rice outside the church. Today, no one does - but everyone has bubbles. How did it happen? One person has the idea at a wedding with 300 guests. Let's say that about a quarter of those guests are young, and half of those are unmarried. So you're looking at about 15-20 unmarried young women at any given wedding. Each of them sees the new idea, and decides that the new idea is something they must do. Let's create a five year window during which 10 of those 15-20 get married. They will spread the idea to another 150-200 marriagable women, who within another 5 years, will spread the idea to 15,000-20,000 of the matrimonially-inclined. Within 15 years, you've had 1.5-2 million women exposed to the idea, and it's no longer novel, it's the norm.
My guess is that in about 1999, a select group of hipsters decided they would break tradition and expressly forbid the DJ from playing the "YMCA." They bragged to their friends about their good taste, and the idea spread like the bubbles. The movement is probably in its early stages of spread right now. And if I'm right, by 2014, you will never hear the "YMCA" again.
Just a theory. Not that it makes wedding music much better. We still get bombarded with the "Electric Slide," and more recently, "Save a Horse, Ride a Cowboy" shows up at every union of souls.
